Does it matter if Jeremy Lin is boring?

Jeremy Lin is labels. Harvard. Asian. Asian American. Taiwanese American. These labels perhaps shrouded his talent from those trained to assess it. To be atypical is to often confront skepticism and bias. It is possible that blinkered assessments once hindered the career of a player who–at the very least–should have been drafted. Now that the kid’s succeeding as a Knick, the albatross is actually flying Lin to heights wings rarely reach. To quote Howard Beck: “The qualities that make Lin unique, and seemingly held him back, are now the qualities that make him a sensation.”

Jeremy Lin isn’t Jeremy Lin. For all the talk of him, there is a conspicuously little to shed light on the man’s personality. We know he is religious, we know he’s been sleeping on his brother’s couch. Beyond that, there is not much to draw from, at least not much publicly projected. People are content to embrace Lin as a symbol for now.

Last year, in the Warriors locker room, Lin sat alone. He was back from a Reno Big Horns relegation, I was excited to pick his brain on the experience. After all, a Harvard grad would have some profound insight on this D-League detour, on how Boston and Reno are culturally similar in a way I never would have guessed, on how Nevada’s pro gambling legislation impacts Reno’s economy like so. Was this whole experience Kafkaesque? Was it a quixotic adventure? Lin kindly, patiently, listened to the questions.

The result was platitudes, ushered out of his mouth by monosyllabic mumbles. The monosyllabism was occasionally interrupted by the throaty trill that creeps into the voice of a nervous speaker. Despite an unusual background, Jeremy delivered clichés like an athlete cliché, normal and boring as they come. For my purposes, the Harvard education was merely, only a label. There was nothing to discuss apart from his game, his background, and how that confluence resonates with fans.

Does it matter if this is who he (publicly) is? Jeremy Lin already represents so much to so many. He may just be able to exist only as a rather successful symbol. Kevin Durant’s appeal is infused with understated charisma, but not everybody needs to follow that plan. Bulls fans know the bullet points on Derrick Rose’s “humility” but Rose guards himself better than anyone in the league does. Chicagoans need not know Derrick to feel connected to the local kid made great.

In a Knicks-era Jeremy Lin interview, you can hear the dry platitudes, the nervous warble. And at the 2:30 mark, you can hear Lin ease into a joke about becoming a permanent houseguest at Casa de Landry Fields. Perhaps Lin is starting to transmit charisma towards the millions he already had at “hello.”

Right now, Jeremy is widely identified with, though largely unknown. With so many in his corner, will he ever even need to be liked for one iota of who he is? Does he need to be anything other than a symbol?


Related posts:

  1. Does point guard defense matter?
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

So - the point of this article is to say that you'd wish that he'd reveal more interesting details about himself and that he'd talk like you'd expect a Harvard grad to talk?

We need money from China, so don't let taiwan issue disturb our economic plan. In this world, Taiwan belongs to China. So Lin is a Chinese American. There is no such thing as so called "Tai*** American". Taiwan is not in UN and will never be. If you wanted to ask Obama and whoever will become the President of US, he or she will tell you Taiwan province belongs to China.

Just so you know I am not blowing hot air, I did missionary work for about a year in Taiwan. I also lived for a year in Chintown, NYC doing church work there as well. At times I felt very connected to the cultures (Taiwanese, ABC, and Mainland Chinese) I was living in and at others I felt very distant and confused. In any case in the long run I came to understand a little bit better the nuances in how people reacted towards me and could splice the facts to make an accurate read of the situation. When I watch Jeremy Lin interview he doesn't seem boring at all. He's humble. He puts his team before himself many times (and I think that he probably finds that a more important interest to invest towards than making himself seem more interesting to people that really serve an ancillary purpose).

Everyone will have their own view about Lin, and as an Asian American I have my own as well. For me, it is important that he seems like a run of the mill asian american in terms of personality and his faith (I am a catholic however, and the protestant way of expressing faith is a bit too much for me) yet is successful in a way that majority of the asians are not. So while I don't care whether he is boring or not, I do want to know more about him, the same way i was propelled to buy and read Jordan Rules, Mad Game, Shaq Uncut and Steve Jobs. It may not matter in that he could do no wrong now to dispel or nullfiy what he has done up to this point, but that doesn't mean that I'm not interested to know more about him and that it doesn't 'matter.'

@Jay What is "contrarian" about this? What is "stupid" about it? And what was "the mainstream" opinion?

Your constant efforts to be contrarian lead you to write some pretty stupid stuff. Sometimes, the mainstream can be right. Most of the time, actually. Embrace it.

@Kevin I DID enjoy the game. It's a fun story, and I wish I'd gotten on the bandwagon sooner.

That's fair. I hope you enjoyed tonight's game. Hopefully, his on-court theatrics will help him open up a bit more.

@Kevin Ya, but what if Lin never lets us get to know him? But I do agree that the article is largely pointless. On a second reading, I believe my points are pretty muddled, perhaps because I was dancing around certain issues that required either more candor or more investigation.

In response to your last comment Ethan, that's worth a lot. In fact, it's worth enough to make this whole article pointless.

I would also like to establish that I had more than a single interaction with Lin, for those who think the impression was based on a one off. I have heard from people that he's quite an interesting dude in person, though (for whatever that's worth)

@Doug I'm still mad he plays sans elbow patches.

Blogger is miraculously disappointed that professional athlete delivers interviews like any other professional athlete and not a cartoon stereotype of an egghead intellecutal, film at 11.

What a flawed text! Why is he boring? What kind of "monosyllabic platitudes" did he utter? True, we don't know much about him. True, the things that hurt him in the past, make him a star now. True, he most likely will not turn out to be the ideal figure many now picture. Yes, there is a lot of exaggeration around J.Lin today. But labeling the man "boring" out of nowhere, without providing any support of your argument, and doing this at a time of total excitement...Well, don't you think you are pushing waaaay too much?

Entire article, to paraphrase: "No"

Good point about how people are able to like him - we don't know HIM at all, just that he's a point guard who had a few good games on the Knicks and that there's basically nothing to DISLIKE about him and his relatively relatable NBA player status. The thing is, if we like what little we know about someone, we're predisposed to like them and we tend to just fill in the gaps in our knowledge with positive assumptions. This is why having a letter of recommendation with 2 great things is better than one with 2 great things and a mediocre thing. People generally assume consistency until given a conflict to ponder. The less you come out and say, the better. If he plays well, there's really nothing to gain at this point by opening up to the storytellers.

I think one of the reasons he is acting "boring" is that he's not looking to cause controversy or seeking extra attention to himself. He knows he could play the race card, ivy card, etc. But, I believe he truly wants to be known for what he can do on the court, not what symbols he represents. And although I personally started following him because of what he represents, I now watch him to see what he will do next on the court.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] star or shatters his glass slipper sitting at the end of the bench is of little importance to me. Ethan Sherwood Strauss may be right. He may never exist as anything other than Jeremy Lin, the symbol — but only because the [...]

  2. [...] star or shatters his glass slipper sitting at the end of the bench is of little importance to me. Ethan Sherwood Strauss may be right. He may never exist as anything other than Jeremy Lin, the symbol — but only because the symbol [...]

  3. [...] after a week of media hoopla and six games’ worth heroics, we don’t really know him. Ethan Sherwood calls him boring. And now I get it. Jeremy is just a symbol. My Asian American brothers at Next Gener.Asian Church [...]

  4. [...] star or shatters his glass slipper sitting at the end of the bench is of little importance to me. Ethan Sherwood Strauss may be right. He may never exist as anything other than Jeremy Lin, the symbol — but only because the symbol [...]

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes